The committee published its 2023 health plan ratings Sept. 15. Plans are rated on a one to five star scale based on quality of care, member satisfaction and plans' efforts to improve.
No Medicaid plans received a five star rating. Here are the plans that received 4.5 and 4-star ratings from the committee:
4.5-star plans
- Capital District Physicians Health Plan (N.Y.)
- Excellus BlueCross BlueShield (N.Y)
- Univera Healthcare (N.Y.)
- Fallon Community Health Plan (Mass.)
- Kaiser Foundation Health Plan of the Mid-Atlantic States (Md.)
- Kaiser Foundation Health Plan (Hawaii)
- Mass General Brigham Health Plan (Mass.)
- Neighborhood Health Plan of Rhode Island
- Tufts Health Public Plans (Mass.)
- UPMC For You (Pa.)
- UnitedHealthcare of New England (R.I.)
- UnitedHealthcare of the Midlands (Neb.)
- AmeriHealth Caritas Pennsylvania Community HealthChoices
4-star plans
- Aetna Better Health of Kentucky
- Alameda Alliance for Health (Calif.)
- Amerigroup Iowa
- Anthem Blue Cross and Blue Shield in Indiana
- Blue Plus (Minn.)
- WellSense Health Plan (Mass.)
- UnitedHealthcare Community Plan (Wisc.)
- Chorus Community Health Plans (Wisc.)
- Community Health Group (Calif.)
- Contra Costa Health Plan (Calif.)
- Aetna Better Health of West Virginia
- Dean Health Plan (Wisc.)
- Highmark Wholecare (Pa.)
- Geisinger Health Plan (Pa.)
- N.H. Health Families
- Health New England (Mass.)
- Health Partners Plans (Pa.)
- HealthPlus HP (N.Y.)
- Highmark BCBSD Health Options (Del.)
- Iowa Total Care
- Jai Medical Systems Managed Care Organization (Md.)
- Molina Healthcare of Florida
- Nebraska Total Care
- Fidelis Care (N.Y)
- CalOptima Health (Calif.)
- PrimeWest Health (Minn.)
- Rocky Mountain Health Maintenance Organization (Colo.)
- San Francisco Health Plan
- Health Plan of San Mateo (Calif.)
- Security Health Plan of Wisconsin
- SelectHealth (Utah)
- UnitedHealthcare Community Plan (Hawaii)
- UnitedHealthcare Community Plan (Tenn.)
- UnitedHealthcare of Pennsylvania
- UnitedHealthcare Community Plan (Va.)
- UnitedHealthcare Community Plan (Kan.)
- Upper Peninsula Health Plan (Mich.)
- AmeriHealth Caritas Pennsylvania
- Keystone First (Pa.)
- Keystone First Community HealthChoices (Pa.)
- BlueCare Tennessee
